Rautray Advocates & Solicitors
Issue 79July 2025
C.A.N.

Construction Arbitration

Newsletter
RAUTRAY & CO.
Construction Arbitration Law Firm
www.rautray.com

Construction Arbitration — Issue 79

Coercion or duress to enter a settlement

Material factors include whether the person allegedly coerced protested, whether an alternative course such as an adequate legal remedy was available, whether independent advice was obtained, and whether steps were taken after the contract to avoid it. Pressure constituting duress must be such that the victim entered the contract against his will, had no alternative course open to him, and faced coercive acts by the other party.

Patel Engineering Ltd. v. Acron Developers Pvt. Ltd.

Failure to produce evidence

If a party fails to produce evidence which it could produce to prove a fact it asserts, the non-production may support a presumption that the evidence would be unfavourable to that party and an adverse inference may be drawn.

Patel Engineering Ltd. v. Acron Developers Pvt. Ltd.

Evidence explaining recitals in a document

Oral evidence may be adduced to show that recitals in a deed were nominal, were not intended to be acted upon, or were not meant to alter the existing state of affairs.

Patel Engineering Ltd. v. Acron Developers Pvt. Ltd.

Labour price variation capped at 45%

Where the contract provides for payment of differential amounts on account of price variation to the extent of 45%, a claim for price variation in excess of 45% for the component of labour is impermissible.

Gammon India Limited v. Konkan Railway Corporation Ltd.

Extra excavation cost for changed tunnel conditions

A Contractor who quoted rates after inspecting the site and familiarising itself with accessibility, working conditions, geological feasibility and terrain conditions cannot claim extra excavation cost merely because the geological conditions encountered required a change in tunnelling methodology and increased costs.

Gammon India Limited v. Konkan Railway Corporation Ltd.
Patel Engineering Ltd. v. Acron Developers Pvt. Ltd.
Bombay High Court — Decided on 14.7.2025

The contract was for carrying out construction work at residential apartments. The timeline to complete the project as per the contract came to an end. The Employer terminated the contract, amongst others, on the ground that the Contractor had failed to achieve the milestones to complete the project as stipulated in the contract.

However, the parties entered into a settlement which recorded that the contract stood revived subject to the modifications as contained in the Deed of Settlement. As per the Deed of Settlement, the timeline to complete the project came to an end. The Contractor requested for extension of time. Fresh timelines for completion of the project were agreed between the parties.

The Contractor contended that all commitments made by it were based upon reciprocal promises to make timely payment of the Running Account (RA) Bills by the Employer. The disputes between the parties were referred to arbitration.

The arbitral tribunal held that the Contractor was not responsible for the delay notwithstanding the recital in the Deed of Settlement entered between the parties. The Employer after execution of the Deed of Settlement did not terminate the contract and instead from time to time extended the time to complete the works by the Contractor. Therefore, time was not the essence of the contract.

The Court upheld the award and observed that the arbitral tribunal had appreciated the evidence on record whilst granting the claims in favour of the Contractor regarding additional expenditure incurred by the Contractor during the extended period of the contract and additional expenditure incurred for retaining its machinery, tools and other equipment at site during the extended period of contract.

Further, the Court observed that the finding on adverse inference to be drawn against the Employer for non-production of the best evidence in defence, by upholding the Contractor's claim that the Employer failed to timely provide the Good For Construction (GFC) drawings, would amount to re-appreciating of evidence, which is not permissible in law.

The Court also considered the circumstances relevant to an allegation of coercion or duress in entering into the settlement. Relevant considerations include whether the person allegedly coerced protested, whether an alternative course such as an adequate legal remedy was available, whether the person was independently advised, and whether steps were taken after entering the contract to avoid it.

Where a party fails to produce evidence which it could have produced to prove a fact asserted by it, the non-production may support an adverse inference that the evidence would have been unfavourable to that party. Oral evidence may also be led to explain a recital or statement in a document, including to establish that a recital was nominal or was not intended to alter the existing state of affairs.

Gammon India Limited v. Konkan Railway Corporation Ltd.
Bombay High Court — Decided on 22.7.2025

The Contractor was awarded the contract for construction of B.G. Single Line Tunnel (Tunnel No. 20 - Karbude Tunnel) in Ratnagiri (North). The Contractor raised disputes upon completion of the works.

The arbitral tribunal allowed some of the claims of the Contractor including reimbursement of difference between price variation on account of increase in minimum wages, and extra cost in excavation of soft strata of tunnel from Bhoke Portal side.

The Contractor contended that while excavating the tunnel, it came across soft strata contrary to the Geo-technical appraisal given in the bid document indicating that the excavation was likely to go across amygdule basalt.

The strata encountered was not rock/dense basalt, but laterite and soft material throughout in 400 metres from Bhoke side. This forced the Contractor to resort to drift method of tunnelling with heavy seepage issues not permitting proper drilling cycle and meeting of unexpected expenditure.

The arbitral tribunal held that there was a significant change in the geographical structure from reasonably hard rock to laterite and soft material forcing the Contractor to change the tunnelling methodology, thereby escalating the overall cost two to three times as compared to hard strata in similar working conditions.

The Court held that the claim of the Contractor towards the price variation in excess of 45% for the 'component of labour' was impermissible as per the contractual conditions.

The Court, while rejecting the claim of the Contractor, held that the Contractor had quoted the rates after inspection of the site and after familiarising all contractual features such as accessibility, working condition, geological feasibility / terrain conditions.

Authors

RAUTRAY & CO.

Law Firm

Dharmendra Rautray &
Ginny Jetley Rautray

B3/18 Vasant Vihar,
Paschimi Marg,
New Delhi – 110057

Tel: +91.11.46552244 / 46113964
E: mail@rautray.com

Rautray & Co. law firm is a Top Tier ranked firm by Asia Pacific Legal 500 in Dispute Resolution for the years 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.