Construction Arbitration — Issue 74
Signing of Final Bill whether amounts to full and final settlement
Signing of Final Bill whether amounts to full and final settlement - mere signature on the final bill does not amount to full and final settlement and does not fall within the four corners of accord and satisfaction, more so when there are letters of discontent and the intention to claim is evident from the record.
Failure to fulfil reciprocal promise by the Employer - non-availability of work front
Failure to fulfil reciprocal promise by the Employer - non-availability of work front - even though the Employer relies on numerous letters alleging shortcomings and lack of due diligence on the part of the Contractor, the Employer cannot overlook its failure to perform its reciprocal promise to provide full site and decisions up to date of completion - non-handing over full site, delayed decisions on drawings etc. prevented the Contractor from working in a planned and systematic manner and impeded the momentum.
Findings in an expert report
Findings in an expert report - expert gave equal opportunity to both the parties for re-measurement of the disputed measurement - reliance of arbitral tribunal on expert report justified if the report has been duly considered in view of the documents and other materials placed on record.
Illegal termination of contract
Illegal termination of contract - whether the conclusion of the arbitral tribunal in holding the termination notice was illegal, can be the basis of rejection of the counter claims of the Employer - no notice of termination was given by the Employer as per the contract - clause in the contract providing that Employer’s election to terminate the contract shall not prejudice any other rights of the Employer, under the contract or otherwise - two separate clauses in the contract providing condition precedent to be satisfied by the Employer before terminating - arbitral tribunal held that there was delay caused by both the parties - Employer justified in electing to invoke one of the clauses in the contract and fulfilling the condition precedent for issuance of termination notice.
The Contractor was awarded the work for restoration and rejuvenation of River Yamuna flood plains from Nizamuddin Bridge to DND Flyway. The Employer had granted extension of time up to the actual date of completion without levying compensation on the ground of COVID-19. The work was completed after a delay of 14 months. The disputes between the parties were referred to arbitration. The arbitral tribunal concluded that mere signature on the final bill does not amount to full and final settlement and does not fall within the four corners of accord and satisfaction, more so when there are letters of discontent and the intention to claim was evident from the documents. Further, the arbitral tribunal held that due to admitted hindrances, the work was delayed and because of the delays, extension of time was granted. The Contractor was entitled to compensation for loss due to prolongation of the contract provided the loss is not too remote or indirect. The Court upholding the arbitral award observed that the arbitral tribunal has not blindly relied on the expert report but has considered the expert report in light of the documents and other materials placed before him by the parties. The construction work involved numerous activities and operations which required advanced planning and mobilization of resources and that there had been delay on the part of the Employer in performing its duties. The failure on the part of the Employer in performing its reciprocal promise had caused huge time afflux thereby disrupting the planning of the Contractor. Even though the Employer relied on numerous letters alleging shortcomings and lack of due diligence on the part of the Contractor, the Employer cannot overlook its failure to perform its reciprocal promise to provide full site and decisions up to date of completion.
The Employer awarded the work for “External Development Works, Road Work, Sewage, Water Supply and Storm Drainage work” to the Contractor. The Employer had granted two extensions of time to the Contractor. Subsequently, the contract was terminated by the Employer. The disputes between the parties were referred to arbitration. The arbitral tribunal concluded that the Employer’s termination was illegal since it failed to give 15 days’ notice to the Contractor under one of the clauses of the contract. The Court observed that the Employer’s termination notice was valid since it had two options available to it under the contract for termination and satisfying the condition precedent of one of the clauses prior to terminating the contract, was sufficient. The Court set aside the arbitral award.
RAUTRAY & CO.
Law Firm
Dharmendra Rautray &
Ginny Jetley Rautray
B3/18 Vasant Vihar,
Paschimi Marg,
New Delhi – 110057
Tel: +91.11.46552244 / 46113964
E: mail@rautray.com
Rautray & Co. law firm is a Top Tier ranked firm by Asia Pacific Legal 500 in Dispute Resolution for the years 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.