Construction Arbitration — Issue 97
Claim for liquidated damages — proof of actual loss
Claim for liquidated damages - proof of actual loss - in the absence of proof of actual damages and without recording a finding that actual damages could not be proved, the arbitral tribunal proceeded to conclude that 10% of the contract value shall be a reasonable damages to be awarded over and above the liquidated damages - basis for quantification is missing and the awarding of damages is vitiated.
Claim for liquidated damages — damages beyond liquidated damages
Claim for liquidated damages - award of damages beyond liquidated damages - performance bank guarantee and liquidated damages clause - damages awarded over and above the liquidated damages, quantified equivalent to the performance bank guarantee - liquidated damages clause and performance bank guarantee clause operate in different fields - liquidated damages clause relates to delay in completion - performance bank guarantee secures due performance and may sustain separate claims for breach - there is no legal bar to award damages beyond liquidated damages if such damages relate to distinct heads not covered by liquidated damages.
Effect of grant of provisional Extension of Time (EOT)
Effect of grant of provisional Extension of Time (EOT) - specific delays mentioned in the hindrance register were attributable to the Employer - reliance placed by the arbitrator on hindrance register cannot be challenged - Employer granted several EOTs but never rescheduled milestone - amounts withheld by the Employer on the basis of the originally agreed milestones are rendered irrelevant where multiple EOTs have been granted without corresponding rescheduling of the milestones - once an extension of time is granted, the originally fixed milestones become irrelevant, and any withholding cannot be justified on the ground that the earlier fixed milestones were not achieved.
Evidentiary value of hindrance register
Evidentiary value if hindrance register - hindrance registers often hold greater evidentiary value regarding the actual impact of weather on specific construction activities like concreting or earthwork than general meteorological data.
Prolongation of contract claims
Prolongation of contract claims - clause in the contract providing “No compensation shall be allowed for any delay caused in the starting of the work on account of acquisition of land, encroachment or in the case of clearance of works, on account of any delay in according sanction to estimates in issue of drawings, decisions, etc. however, the extension of time shall be granted” - whether there was a specific consent by the Contractor to accept only extension of time in full satisfaction of any delay claims - clause will not apply if the delays are attributable to the Employer alone.
Claim on account of increases in statutory payment of minimum wages
Claim on account of increases in statutory payment of minimum wages - Contractor had produced supporting documents evidencing payment of minimum wages - Contractor had quantified its claim by adopting the labour component and formula analogous to provision of the CPWD contract - arbitral tribunal granted actual expenditure incurred / actual payments made to labour - the award of claim by the arbitral tribunal was valid since the tribunal did not rely on the provision of the CPWD contract - mere fact that the arbitral tribunal did not expressly refer to a particular clause of the contract in the award cannot constitute a ground for challenging the award.
The Contractor was awarded a lump-sum turnkey contract by the Employer for installation of one Effluent Treatment Plant and three ETP-cum-Water Injection Plants at four sites in Assam, together with seven years’ maintenance. Disputes arose during execution. According to the Employer, the Contractor performed only 5.86% of the contractual work and abandoned the project. The Employer invoked the advance bank guarantee, the performance bank guarantee and terminated the contract. The Employer raised substantial monetary counter claims. The disputes between the parties were referred to arbitration.
The Contractor claimed prolongation cost, breach losses, damages for blacklisting, and refund of illegally invoked bank guarantees. The arbitral tribunal held in favour of the Contractor in respect of soil investigation charges and refund of advance bank guarantee. The Employer’s counter claim for liquidated damages was allowed. The arbitral tribunal upheld the invocation of performance bank guarantee and observed that amount equivalent to the performance bank guarantee would constitute “reasonable damages”.
The Court concluded that an Employer may validly invoke a performance bank guarantee upon contractor’s breach; however, encashed performance bank guarantee amount cannot automatically be appropriated as damages unless the arbitral tribunal records proof of actual loss, or reasons why actual loss is incapable of proof, and a rational/intelligible basis for assessing reasonable compensation.
Awarding damages merely equivalent to performance bank guarantee amount after rejecting substantive damage claims for lack of evidence is self-contradictory, violative of section 73 Contract Act, violative of section 31(3) Arbitration Act, and liable to be set aside under section 34.
The Employer awarded the Contractor the works, including the preparation of designs and the construction of the Medical College & Hostel Complex at AIIMS, Bhopal. Package-I. During the execution of the works under the contract, certain issues arose between the parties, which were referred to arbitration. The arbitral tribunal allowed most of the claims raised by the Contractor.
The Employer contended that the grant of provisional EOTs did not imply that the delays stood condoned or admitted. The provisional EOTs were granted to keep the contract alive and expressly reserved the Employer’s right to claim compensation for delays attributable to the Contractor.
The Court concluded that the specific delays mentioned in the hindrance register were attributable to the Employer. Reliance was further placed on the hindrance register, and it was reasoned that the Contractor observed that the clause in the contract providing that the Contractor is entitled only to an extension of time in full satisfaction of any delay claims would not apply where the arbitral tribunal found that the delays were attributable solely to the Employer.
The arbitral tribunal did not disregard the contract clauses but consciously reconciled them with Sections 53, 55, and 73 of the Contract Act while awarding damages. Further, the amounts withheld by the Employer on account of the originally agreed milestones were irrelevant in light of the several EOTs granted by the Employer without rescheduling the said milestones. Once extensions are granted in view of the originally fixed milestones becoming irrelevant, any withholding cannot be justified on the ground that the earlier fixed milestones were not achieved.
RAUTRAY & CO.
Law Firm
Dharmendra Rautray &
Ginny Jetley Rautray
B3/18 Vasant Vihar,
Paschimi Marg,
New Delhi – 110057
Tel: +91.11.46552244 / 46113964
E: mail@rautray.com
Rautray & Co. law firm is a Top Tier ranked firm by Asia Pacific Legal 500 in Dispute Resolution for the years 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.