Construction Arbitration — Issue 95
Delay in providing Right of Way (ROW)
Delay in providing Right of Way (ROW) - extension of time - definition of the term ‘encumbrances’ - whether the said term excluded utilities and roads - commercial operation date could not be achieved - identification and shifting of utilities was within the scope of the Employer - obligation of the Employer to provide site / ROW free from all encumbrances including utilities.
Access to the site
Access to the site - whether it was Employer’s obligation to make available the site / ROW free from all encumbrances and after diversion of utilities - contention that utilities had to be removed / relocated only as and when during the progress of the construction, a stage arose where such utilities obstructed further construction activity, is contrary to the express terms of the Concession Agreement (CA) - construction work cannot be conducted in a piecemeal manner - Concessionaire not expected to have separate or different resources such as manpower, machinery and material etc., for each of the activity, that too for open ended period.
Concurrent delays
Concurrent delays - if there exist concurrent delay, the Contractor is only entitled to extension of time and cannot recover damages for loss caused by delay - because the rule where delay is caused by the Employer is that, not only must the Contractor complete within a reasonable time but also the Contractor must have a reasonable time within which to complete - since the last hindrance was removed few months before commercial operations commenced, the general rule discussed in De Beers case of grant of only extension of time and not damages in case involving concurrent delay by Contractor is not attracted.
No claim clause
No claim clause - stipulation in the contract restricting right of a party to claim damages on commission of breach by opposite party is not enforceable - restricting right of a party to claim compensation/damages would be void as being against public interest and public policy.
Piecemeal handing over of site
Piecemeal handing over of site - effect on construction work - programme chart including the description of activity, the start and finish dates showed that the Concessionaire proposed to carry out the work sequentially and not in piecemeal manner - the activities were to be undertaken / completed within a particular period for the entire line and each subsequent activity, with its own time frame, was dependent on prior activity - accordingly, considering that the activities had to be carried out within specified time frames, the Concessionaire was required to mobilize resources, manpower plant and machinery etc. - not expected to have separate or different resources such as manpower, machinery and material etc., for each of the activity that too for open ended period - if the arbitral tribunal while conducting enquiry into the aspect of delay has divided the number of sub-stretches in large numbers and merely because the Employer is absolved in respect of allegations of delay for few sub-stretches, the same would not mean that the overall finding of the arbitral tribunal about the Concessionaire being responsible for such delay suffers from an element of perversity.
Delay in providing ROW — remedy of damages
Contract does not provide for remedy of seeking damages or monetary compensation for delay in providing ROW - remedy of extension of concession period provided - no specific bar to remedy of damages - claim for compensation / damages of the Concessionaire can be adjudicated even though concession agreement provided for only extension of concession period as a consequence for delay.
Additional overheads and supervision
Claim for additional overheads and supervision of constructions works - evidence in support of claim - only tabular statement produced - Concessionaire’s witness not aware of who carried out the identification of overhead expenses in the management - witness did not have any personal knowledge about alleged expenditure, no other evidence was produced to demonstrate that any additional expenditure was indeed incurred - daily cashflow details, bills, invoices, ledgers, books of accounts not produced to substantiate the claim - award of the arbitral tribunal on the basis of presumption that the Concessionaire would have had to employ manpower and machinery for its execution and retain the requisite manpower and by having to deploy the requisite machinery etc., during the extended period - findings of the arbitral tribunal and award is liable to be set aside.
Dissenting opinion of minority award
Relevance of dissenting opinion of a minority award - can be relied upon by the party seeking to set aside the award to buttress its submissions in the proceedings challenging the award - court is not precluded from considering the findings and conclusions of the dissenting opinion of the minority member of the arbitral tribunal - although it does not form part of the award, but it may be admissible as evidence in relation to the procedural matters in the event of a challenge or may add weight to the arguments of a party wishing to appeal against the award.
‘Loss of Profit’ and ‘Loss of Profitability’
‘Loss of Profit’ and ‘Loss of Profitability’ - difference - loss of profit will be awarded where there is breach of contract inasmuch as the rescission of contract by the Employer is held to be unjustified, and the Contractor had executed a part of the works contract, the Contractor would be entitled to damages by way of loss of profit - while loss of profit indicates claims for loss of expected profit due to unexecuted work resulting from an illegal or premature termination of the contract, loss of profitability of loss of business signifies claims for reduction in the estimated profit margin due to prolongation of the contract or claims for loss of opportunity to take up other projects during the extended period where the Contractor could have earned a profit.
Loss due to illegal termination of contract
Loss due to illegal termination of contract - proof of loss suffered - once the Contractor has established an illegal and unjustified termination of contract and a breach thereof on the part of the Employer, which was also a finding of fact by the sole arbitrator, the Contractor cannot be further obligated to establish a loss suffered on account of such breach, because a reasonable expectation of profit is implicit in a works contract - compensation must be reasonable and the parties should not be allowed to make a windfall profit, by a mere allegation of breach of contract.
Damages / compensation due to prolongation
Claim for damages / compensation due to prolongation of contract - falls under the head of ‘loss of profitability’ - claim for additional overhead expenses would fall under the former head of ‘loss of profitability’ - production of direct evidence is mandatory and in absence of which, the claim for damages cannot be allowed - Hudson's Formula may be useful when needed but that cannot alone prove Contractor's loss of profits - formula can only be used if the Contractor has shown with evidence the loss of profits and loss of opportunities it suffered owing to the prolongation - imperative for the Contractor to substantiate the presence of a viable opportunity through compelling evidence - it may generally include independent contemporaneous evidence such as other potential projects that the Contractor had in the pipeline that could have been undertaken if not for the delays, the total number of tendering opportunities that the Contractor received and declined owing to the prolongation of the contract, financial statements, or any clauses in the contract related to delays, extensions of time, and compensation for loss of profit.
Evidence in support of loss of profit, profitability or opportunities
Evidence in support of claim for loss of profit, profitability or opportunities - the Contractor / Concessionaire must establish that first, there was a delay in the completion of the contract; second, such delay is not attributable to the Contractor; third, the Contractor's status as an established Contractor, handling substantial projects; and fourth, credible evidence to substantiate the claim of loss of profitability.
Change of scope
Change of scope - failure to issue notice of change - Employer did not stop the Concessionaire from proceeding as per changed scope - once the change in scope as contemplated took place and the Concessionaire undertook the work based on instructions of the Employer, the Employer cannot deny the compensation contemplated under the CA by citing its own failure or the failure of IE to arrive at the additional cost.
Severance of award
Severance of award - power of partial setting aside should be exercised only when the valid and invalid parts of the award can be clearly segregated particularly in relation to liability and quantum and without any corelation between valid and invalid parts - Court can apply the doctrine of severability and modify a portion of the award while retaining the rest.
Award of damages without evidence of loss suffered
Award of damages without evidence of loss suffered - mere entries in the books of accounts depicting sufferance of loss are not sufficient for awarding the claim in absence of any supporting evidence - liability cannot be saddled merely on the basis of entries in books of accounts in absence of evidence.
Occurrence of defect after completion certificate
Occurrence of defect after issuance of completion certificate - on the date when the completion certificate was given, no apparent defect was identified regarding the safe bearing capacity of the piles - tilting of piles had taken place since the design and build of segmental precast driven piles did not meet the design requirement - completion certificate, by itself, cannot be construed to absolve the Contractor from the responsibility for adequacy of the design prepared by the Contractor and will not absolve the Contractor from the liability in respect of the work done.
The disputes and differences between the parties arose out of Concession Agreement executed for the setting up of Mass Rapid Transit System along the Versova-Andheri-Ghatkopar Corridor. The obligations of the Employer included grant of access to the Concessionaire to the site including Right of Way (ROW), leasing land for Car Depot, providing electric sub-stations and access to stations and land temporarily for construction of elevated track way, station buildings and staircases as envisaged under the Concession Agreement. The concession period was 35 years. The Employer was to provide access to site, free from encumbrances in six identified stretches of a total length of 11.332 Kms. The delay in implementation of the Project resulted in increase in the cost of the Project.
The Concessionaire was required to obtain necessary approvals from Western Railways and the Western Railway gave in-principle approval to the Concessionaire for construction of a segmental concrete bridge at Andheri. The Independent Engineer recommended extension of construction due to delay in providing the ROW. The arbitral tribunal concluded that the contention that utilities had to be removed/relocated only as and when during the progress of the construction a stage arose where such utilities obstructed further construction activity, is contrary to the express terms of the CA. Thus, the arbitral tribunal held that identification and shifting of utilities was within the domain of the Employer and has accordingly concluded that it was the obligation of the Employer to provide site/ ROW free from all encumbrances including utilities.
The arbitral tribunal also concluded that since the Independent Engineer (IE) being a technical expert appointed in terms of CA, could recommend extension of COD and concession period only if delay was not attributable to the Concessionaire and that since Employer unconditionally extended COD by 540 days, it cannot be contended that delay for that period could be attributable to the Concessionaire. The arbitral tribunal rejected the contention that the construction work could be conducted in a piecemeal manner and concluded that the work was supposed to be carried out sequentially.
The Court concluded that the judgment in De Beers would have no application to the facts of the present case. Since the last hindrance was removed a few months before commercial operations commenced, the general rule discussed in De Beers case of grant of only extension of time and not damages in cases involving concurrent delay by Contractor is not attracted. Findings of the arbitral tribunal holding the Employer to be in overall delay cannot be set aside simply by selectively relying on some of the findings where the Employer is absolved in respect of allegations of delay.
Award of claim for additional overheads and supervision of construction works by the arbitral tribunal on the basis of the magnitude of the project and presumption that the Concessionaire would have had to incur additional costs by being required to retain manpower and by having to deploy the requisite machinery etc., was held to be perverse. The principle of guesswork cannot be applied in a case where the party has failed to produce evidence.
The Court also considered the effect of the concession agreement providing for extension of the concession period as the consequence of delay in providing ROW. Since there was no specific bar to a remedy of damages, a claim for compensation / damages could be adjudicated even though the concession agreement provided for only extension of concession period as a consequence for delay.
The Court further considered the distinction between loss of profit and loss of profitability. Loss of profit may arise where rescission of the contract is held to be unjustified after the Contractor has executed part of the works, whereas loss of profitability or loss of business concerns reduction in the estimated profit margin due to prolongation or loss of opportunity to take up other projects during the extended period. For claims based on prolongation and loss of profitability, direct and credible evidence is required. Hudson’s Formula may be useful when needed, but it cannot alone prove the Contractor’s loss of profits or opportunities.
The Contractor / Concessionaire must establish that there was a delay in completion of the contract, that the delay was not attributable to it, that it was an established Contractor handling substantial projects, and that credible evidence substantiated the claim of loss of profitability. Relevant evidence may include contemporaneous evidence of potential projects, tendering opportunities declined because of prolongation, financial statements, and contractual provisions dealing with delays, extensions of time and compensation for loss of profit.
On change of scope, where the contemplated change took place and the Concessionaire undertook the work based on instructions of the Employer, the Employer could not deny compensation contemplated under the CA by citing its own failure or the failure of the Independent Engineer to arrive at the additional cost.
As to severance, the power of partial setting aside should be exercised only where valid and invalid parts of the award can be clearly segregated, particularly in relation to liability and quantum and without correlation between valid and invalid parts. The Court can apply the doctrine of severability and modify a portion of the award while retaining the rest.
On damages without evidence of loss, mere entries in books of accounts depicting sufferance of loss are not sufficient for awarding a claim in the absence of supporting evidence; liability cannot be saddled merely on the basis of entries in books of accounts in the absence of evidence.
The Employer awarded to the Contractor the contract for pile foundation qua a residential project which is construction of a superstructure. The tender envisaged the use of RCC Bored Cast-In-Situ Piles, which were also known as DMC Piles. The Contractor gave a counter offer to install RCC driven precast segmental piles instead of the DMC piles. The Employer requested the Contractor to submit their loading detail drawing and design data in order to evaluate mathematical computation based on soil investigation report.
In furtherance of the work order, the Contractor completed the piling work to the satisfaction of the Employer. The Contractor pointed out that the pre-cast driven piles installed by the Contractor passed all the load tests conducted under the supervision of the Employer and its consultants and thereby the Contractor established the load bearing capacity and stability of the said piles. The completion certificate was also issued. Subsequently, the Employer informed the Contractor that certain piles were tilted / out of plumb. The Employer contended that the pre-cast piles installed based on the Contractor’s design and technology were a failure. The disputes between the parties were referred to arbitration.
The Contractor contended that the arbitral tribunal disregarded the inconsistencies contained in the soil investigation report compiled by the consultants and went wrong in relying upon a different formula instead of using the dynamic formula, which was more reliable than the static formula due to ambiguity in the soil investigation report. The arbitral tribunal arrived at a finding that tilting of piles was on account of possible deficiency in the design as well as the methodology of installation adopted and that it could not be attributed to the mechanical excavation.
The Court concluded that the finding of the arbitral tribunal was a plausible view after considering the various expert reports. The completion certificate, by itself, could not be construed to absolve the Contractor from responsibility for the adequacy of the design prepared by the Contractor and did not absolve the Contractor from liability in respect of the work done.
RAUTRAY & CO.
Law Firm
Dharmendra Rautray &
Ginny Jetley Rautray
B3/18 Vasant Vihar,
Paschimi Marg,
New Delhi – 110057
Tel: +91.11.46552244 / 46113964
E: mail@rautray.com
Rautray & Co. law firm is a Top Tier ranked firm by Asia Pacific Legal 500 in Dispute Resolution for the years 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.