Construction Arbitration — Issue 94
Levy of liquidated damages and reasonable compensation
Levy of liquidated damages - reduction of stipulated liquidated damages - project having public utility implications - modification of award by the Court - defaulting party cannot later insist that the Employer prove exact pecuniary loss - burden is on the defaulting party to show that no loss occurred, or the stipulated amount is penal / unconscionable - award of nominal amount inconsistent with contractual stipulations - Court cannot substitute its own calculation merely because another view is possible - Court cannot proceed to re-work and re-calculate the amount of reasonable compensation once determined.
Extension of time, right of way and judicial deference
Extension of time granted without any compensation or cost escalation - implication of delay in obtaining the right of way for timely completion - role of the state body under the contract - instrumentality of the State would be best placed to engage with other instrumentalities of the State in obtaining approvals as serious as the right of way to dig up land and lay pipelines - Court cannot interfere with the arbitral tribunal’s interpretation of evidence.
Conflict between FIDIC Conditions and Tender Terms
Conflict between the FIDIC Conditions and the Tender Terms - interplay between the terms of the FIDIC and the General Conditions of Contract (GCC) - under the FIDIC Conditions, the delay in providing right of way led to an extension of time coupled with compensation whereas under the Tender Terms the delay in right of way would lead to only extension of time without compensation - contract-forming provisions governing the relationship between the parties was an amalgam of the Tender Terms and the FIDIC Conditions - not unreasonable to conclude that the FIDIC Conditions would govern the area of conflict between the two instruments - Court must lean in favour of giving deference to such logical and fair outcome rather than look for reasons to set aside the arbitral award - analysis relating to the conflict between the FIDIC Conditions and the Tender Terms fell within the domain of interpretation of contract that formed subject matter of the arbitral tribunal's jurisdiction - Court cannot substitute the views of the arbitral tribunal with its own views to set aside the arbitral award.
Dispute arose between the Employer and the Contractor in respect of work relating to a solar power project. The Contractor agreed to establish and commission a 20 MW solar power plant and supply electricity to the Employer. There was delay in commissioning of the plant and the Employer invoked the liquidated damages clause under the contract for the delay in commencement of supply. The parties referred the disputes to arbitration.
The majority arbitral award granted only part of the liquidated damages amount as damages. The Single Judge of the High Court set aside the majority award and increased the liquidated damages to 50% of the contractual amount. The Division Bench reduced the amount of liquidated damages awarded to the Employer.
The Supreme Court concluded that the project involved public interest and environmental objectives and that delay in implementation itself causes public detriment. Modification of the award so as to enhance the amount of reasonable compensation by the Court was held to be a permissible exercise. The burden was on the party committing the breach to show that no loss was caused by the delay or that the amount stipulated as liquidated damages was in the nature of a penalty.
The Contractor could not contend that the Employer had failed to indicate the exact loss suffered by it due to the delay in commissioning of the project. The Division Bench exceeded its jurisdiction when it proceeded to re-work and re-calculate the amount of reasonable compensation. Where the parties had pre-estimated the loss likely to be caused, it would be unjustified to conclude that the party that committed the breach was not liable to pay compensation.
The disputes between the parties relate to a project awarded by the Employer to the Contractor for laying pipelines in Navi Mumbai under a deferred payment scheme. The right of way over land on which pipelines had to be laid was handed over, but the last parcel of land was actually received after approximately two years, while the project was to be completed within one year.
The Contractor claimed damages towards increase in financing costs on account of delayed release of instalment payments. The Contractor also made a claim for price escalation during the extended contract and for the cost of extended stay for the project. The arbitral tribunal held that the contract between the parties was to be interpreted in a manner that the FIDIC Conditions and the Escrow Agreement would override the Tender Terms where a conflict emerged.
The arbitral tribunal held that the Employer was entirely responsible for providing the right of way at its own cost and time and, in the event of delay, the Contractor was entitled to time extension and cost compensation for such delay. The Court hearing the challenge to the award concluded that while the Employer was only required to make the applications and pay the requisite fees towards the right of way, securing the right of way was entirely the Contractor's obligation with cost implications for its own account in the event of delay.
The Court in appeal concluded that once the evidence on record reasonably and plausibly pointed to the adoption of FIDIC Conditions, which provide that the Contractor would be entitled to compensation on account of delay in right of way being made available, the arbitral award could not be faulted in its analysis of the consequences of delay. Under the FIDIC Conditions, delay in providing right of way would lead to an extension of time coupled with compensation whereas under the Tender Terms the delay would lead to only extension of time without compensation.
If an arbitral award returns a fair finding, and could be justified by any logical reasons that may not have been explicitly set out by the arbitrator, the Court must lean in favour of giving deference to such logical and fair outcome rather than look for reasons to set aside the arbitral award. It was reasonable and plausible to interpret the Contractor's obligation to obtain the right of way as the obligation to engage with the requisite officials of State agencies to facilitate securing the right of way. The Court upheld the arbitral award.
RAUTRAY & CO.
Law Firm
Dharmendra Rautray &
Ginny Jetley Rautray
B3/18 Vasant Vihar,
Paschimi Marg,
New Delhi – 110057
Tel: +91.11.46552244 / 46113964
E: mail@rautray.com
Rautray & Co. law firm is a Top Tier ranked firm by Asia Pacific Legal 500 in Dispute Resolution for the years 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.