Construction Arbitration — Issue 93
Society of Construction Law Delay and Disruption Protocol
Society of Construction Law Delay and Disruption Protocol - delay analysis method - common sense approach to the delay issues - applicability - for the purpose of any particular case, the fact that a delay analysis method appears in the Protocol does not give it any standing, and the fact that a method, which is otherwise logical or rational, but does not appear in the Protocol, does not deny it standing.
Delay Analysis
Delay Analysis - appropriate methodology for delay analysis - expert evidence - delay claims require credible, evidence-based programming analysis - Courts are not bound to accept expert delay models without factual foundation - where Employer’s own conduct contributes to delay, causation may fail - regardless of the method, the result must pass a "common sense" test - only appropriate method of delay analysis was close consideration and examination of the actual evidence of what was happening on the ground.
Claim for delay damages
Claim for delay damages - claim will fail where the Claimant does not establish, by cogent and factually grounded evidence, that the Defendant’s breach caused delay to the project’s critical path and resulted in quantifiable loss, particularly where the Claimant’s own conduct contributed to the delay - delay claims in construction projects demand strict proof of breach, causation, and quantifiable loss - delay claims must demonstrate impact on the critical path.
Reliability of expert evidence
Reliability of expert evidence - methodologies unsupported by project records or facts should be rejected - delay analysis that does not account for actual site progress is unreliable - court-appointed expert concluded that neither of the methods used by the parties' experts was appropriate to be adopted in this case.
Non-availability of work fronts
Non-availability of work fronts - delays and disruptions to the works due to the delay in the sewer approval - witness stated that the works were delayed, piecemeal and disrupted and that it was the availability of work fronts which drove where work was carried out on any given day - witness affidavit evidence couched in generalities is incapable of founding any satisfactory specific findings of delay - primary source of evidence as to what was happening on the ground is the site diary.
Non-issuance of notice invoking arbitration under Section 21
Non-issuance of notice invoking arbitration under section 21 of the 1996 Act - section 21 is concerned only with determining the commencement of the dispute for the purpose of reckoning limitation - no mandatory prerequisite for issuance of a section 21 notice prior to the commencement of arbitration - failure to issue a section 21 notice would not be fatal to a party in arbitration if the claim is otherwise valid and the disputes arbitrable - claimant is not bound to restrict his statement of claim to the claims raised by him in the notice issued, if any, before - claimant can also amend or supplement the claims in the claim statement unless the arbitration agreement requires the arbitrator to decide only the specifically referred disputes.
Foreclosure to raise entire dispute before the arbitral tribunal
Foreclosure to raise entire dispute before the arbitral tribunal - clause in the GCC providing either party can refer the decision of the adjudicator to the arbitrator within 28 days of the adjudicator's written decision and if neither party refers the dispute to the adjudicator within 28 days, the adjudicator's decision will be final and binding - after the expiry of 56 days that the Employer issued the letter which they claimed was the reference of the decision in dispute no. 1 of the adjudicator - conduct of the Employer precluded it from relying on the mandate of clause 24, 24.1 and 25 of the GCC - prayer of the Employer to declare the adjudicator's decision as null and void indicated their intention to reopen the four disputes originally brought for consideration.
Jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal to entertain any counterclaim
Jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal to entertain any counterclaim - arbitrator will have jurisdiction even though it was not raised at a stage earlier to the stage of pleadings before the arbitrator - where however the arbitration agreement requires specific disputes to be referred to arbitration and provides that the arbitrator will have the jurisdiction to decide only the disputes so referred, the arbitrator's jurisdiction is controlled by the specific reference and he cannot travel beyond the reference, nor entertain any additional claims or counterclaims which are not part of the disputes specifically referred to arbitration.
White Constructions Pty Ltd, the developer of a 100-lot residential subdivision in Kiama, New South Wales, engaged PBS Holdings Pty Ltd as the Water Servicing Coordinator (SWC) and Illawarra Water & Sewer Design Pty Ltd (IWS) as the sewer designer. The project required approval from Sydney Water, including the issuance of a Section 73 Compliance Certificate, before subdivision registration.
The dispute arose from delays in obtaining approval for the sewer design. IWS initially proposed a pumping station solution, which was rejected by Sydney Water. The authority required consideration of alternative designs, particularly a gravity (underbore) sewer system. White Constructions alleged that IWS failed to provide an acceptable design within a reasonable time; PBS failed to properly coordinate and supervise the design process; and these failures caused significant delay to the project, leading to financial losses and contractor claims.
The defendants contended that the plaintiff's own project manager instructed IWS not to pursue the gravity option initially; any delay was largely attributable to the plaintiff's decisions and other project factors; and the sewer works did not delay the overall project's critical path. The Court found that the plaintiff influenced and controlled the design process, including directing the designer away from the gravity option at an early stage. IWS acted in accordance with the plaintiff's instructions and did not breach its obligations.
On delay, the Court held that the plaintiff failed to prove that the sewer design delay affected the critical path of the project. Competing expert delay analyses were unpersuasive and lacked proper factual foundation. The plaintiff failed to establish a direct causal link between the sewer design delay and the overall project delay. On damages, the plaintiff failed to establish a clear causal link between alleged delays and the losses claimed. The damages were found to be speculative and unproven.
The Contractor was awarded a contract for development of roads in Kerala, comprising four packages of Road Maintenance as part of the Kerala State Transport Project. Since the Executive Engineer/Superintending Engineer failed to take any decision, the Contractor approached the adjudicator for decision on pending payments.
The disputes before the adjudicator concerned the value of work to be considered for calculating price adjustment for bitumen and POL, release of escalation during extended periods, the price of bitumen to be considered for calculation of price adjustment, and interest payable at 12% per annum for delay in releasing eligible payments beyond 42 hours from submission of the monthly statement of value of work under Clauses 42.2 and 43.1 of the GCC. The adjudicator ruled in favour of the Contractor on two disputes. The Employer did not settle the bill and the matter was referred to arbitration, where the arbitral tribunal ruled in favour of the Contractor on all four disputes.
The Court concluded that there is no mandatory prerequisite for issuance of a Section 21 notice prior to commencement of arbitration. Issuance of a Section 21 notice may assist the parties and the arbitrator in determining limitation, but failure to issue the notice is not fatal where the claim is otherwise valid and the disputes are arbitrable.
Further, merely because a party did not issue a notice raising counterclaims, it is not precluded from raising the same before the arbitral tribunal, as long as such counterclaims fall within the scope of the arbitration agreement. The claimant is not bound to restrict its statement of claim to claims already raised by notice, unless the parties have otherwise agreed as to the required elements of the claim statement.
RAUTRAY & CO.
Law Firm
Dharmendra Rautray &
Ginny Jetley Rautray
B3/18 Vasant Vihar,
Paschimi Marg,
New Delhi – 110057
Tel: +91.11.46552244 / 46113964
E: mail@rautray.com
Rautray & Co. law firm is a Top Tier ranked firm by Asia Pacific Legal 500 in Dispute Resolution for the years 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.