Construction Arbitration — Issue 92
No compensation clause
Delay in handing over the land required for the work - contract prohibited grant of compensation - once the breach of the contract is noticed at the instance of the Employer, the Employer cannot fall back upon the clause of contract which provides that there shall be no escalatory price for delayed work - when a party has failed to standby it's part of the contract, it is not available for the defaulting party to insist upon implementation of the clauses of the contract providing for no claim for idling of machinery or escalation of price.
Building and Other Construction Workers cess
Whether the BOCW Act and the Cess Act can be treated as ‘subsequent legislation’ - arbitral tribunals held that these Acts did qualify as ‘subsequent legislation’ - in the absence of machinery for levy, collection and deposit of cess, the question of levying and collecting cess cannot logically arise - contract document provided that the time-frame of twenty-eight days before the last date for submission of the bid was crucial to ascertain what should be factored into the prices and rates in the bid offer - Employer cannot recover the cess amount from the Contractor in view of the ‘subsequent legislation’ clause - cess could not have been levied or collected before the constitution of such Welfare Boards.
The Contractor was awarded the work for repair, renovation and restoration of 19 minor irrigation tanks in District Beed, Maharashtra. The contract period was for 12 months. Due to prolongation of work for about 3 years from the due date of completion, dispute arose. The work order was itself conditional and the silt survey was required to be completed by the department. However, the survey work was not completed. Thereafter, the rainy season commenced and it was not possible for the Contractor to carry out the work of silt removal in the rainy season of four months.
The primary contention of the Employer was that the arbitral tribunal could not travel beyond the terms of the contract, more particularly, that there can be no grant of escalatory price or any amount for idling of machinery and labour. The Court rejected the contention of the Employer on the ground that the Employer was in breach of the contract.
The Court observed that the claim granted with respect to loss of overhead and reduction in productivity of men, machinery and equipment cannot be interfered with. The Court further observed that notwithstanding the clauses in the contract, when the party has failed to standby its part of the contract, it is not available for the defaulting party to insist upon implementation of the clauses of the contract providing for no claim for idling of machinery or escalation of price.
The Employer / NHAI contended that, notwithstanding the delayed constitution of Welfare Boards and lack of effective implementation, both the enactments should be construed to have come into effect on the dates notified, i.e. 01.03.1996 (BOCW Act) and 03.11.1995 (Cess Act) and they cannot, therefore, be taken to be ‘subsequent legislation’ under its contractual clauses. The rate of the cess to be collected, i.e. at 1% of the cost of construction, was specified by the Central Government on 26.09.1996 and therefore the Contractors cannot claim ignorance thereof and they ought to have factored in the same in their price bids while submitting tenders for its works. Further, the cess was deductible irrespective of the constitution of Welfare Boards.
The Court observed that in the absence of such machinery, the question of levying and collecting cess cannot logically arise. In the absence of a Welfare Board, even if the cess is deducted at source, be it by a Government or by a Public Sector Unit while making bill payments, the same could not be deposited as per Rule 5.
Though the BOCW Act and the Cess Act were enacted, along with the Rules framed thereunder, they were not given actual effect owing to the complete absence of the required machinery for the levy, collection, deposit and utilisation of the cess to be collected thereunder for the benefit of building and other construction workers. The Contractors could not have factored such cess component into their bid prices prior to a mechanism being put in place for its collection, as that would have led to unjust and unlawful enrichment on their part.
Therefore, the constitution of Welfare Boards is the sine qua non for giving effect to the BOCW Act and the Cess Act and the cess in connection therewith could not have been levied or collected before the constitution of such Welfare Boards. The Court upheld the arbitral awards.
RAUTRAY & CO.
Law Firm
Dharmendra Rautray &
Ginny Jetley Rautray
B3/18 Vasant Vihar,
Paschimi Marg,
New Delhi – 110057
Tel: +91.11.46552244 / 46113964
E: mail@rautray.com
Rautray & Co. law firm is a Top Tier ranked firm by Asia Pacific Legal 500 in Dispute Resolution for the years 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.