Construction Arbitration — Issue 91
No dues certificate and accord and satisfaction
No dues certificate - payment of final bill - accord and satisfaction - Contractor had at no point of time, raised the ground of coercion and duress - Contractor accepted the payment without any protest and almost after 3 years raised a protest on the ground of coercion and duress - hence, there was accord and satisfaction and full and final settlement.
Plea of coercion and descoping of work
Plea of coercion - descoping of work - loss of profit - certification of the completion of the project was held up due to the thirteen buildings - consequently led to holding up of the final bill, securities, bank guarantees, etc. - inability of the Employer to get the buildings vacated from users led to deletion of some buildings and regularization through amendment to contract - no alternative with Contractor for getting the work completion certificate without signing the said amendment - amendment to the contract was under coercion - demolition of the thirteen buildings would have entitled the Contractor to sell the scrap recovered from the said demolition in the market.
Material escalation and freezing of indices
Claim for material escalation - contract provided for freezing of indices - Employer having delayed the works by not handing over buildings for demolition - there was no possibility of the Contractor planning to purchase material before completion of work, which was the basis of freezing indices - Contractor was justified in seeking price escalation on account of an extension of time for the completion of work.
Labour charge escalation and actual reimbursement
Labour charge escalation - 20% higher labour charges were in fact payable for high rise buildings executed under the contract - Central Government Gazette Notification was issued after the date of receipt of the tender - compliance with the Notification was a legal obligation of the Contractor - the claim was for actual reimbursement and therefore payable.
Interpretation of tender scope
Construction of toilet block - tender failed to specifically enlist the construction of the toilet block - gives right to a legitimate understanding of the Contractor that the toilet block was not included in the scope of the Contractor - no scope of interference with the award - interpretation of the scope of the tender falls within the arbitral tribunal’s jurisdiction.
The Contractor was awarded the work for the design, procurement and erection of tankages for its Euro IV Project at Manali, Chennai. The stipulated period for completion of the work was 15 months. However, the completion of the work was delayed. The Employer recovered liquidated damages from the Contractor. In the course of execution of the contract, the Contractor was required to carry out certain additional / extra works. The disputes between the parties were referred to arbitration. The Contractor raised claims for reimbursement of Tax deducted at Source (TDS) amounts, amount for extra / additional works executed, additional bank guarantee extension charges, prolongation costs / overheads for the extended contract period, and interest on delayed payments of various bills. The Employer contended that the Contractor had submitted “no-claim” and “no-due” certificates and received payment towards the final bill.
Further, extensions of time were granted provisionally and without prejudice to the Employer’s right to levy liquidated damages for the delay attributable to the Contractor. The arbitral tribunal rejected most of the claims of the Contractor and arrived at a finding that the Contractor had at no point of time raised the ground of coercion and duress.
The Court observed that the Contractor accepted the payment without any protest and almost after 3 years raised a protest on the ground of coercion and duress as an afterthought. The Court upheld the findings of the arbitral tribunal on the issue of accord and satisfaction and full and final settlement.
The Contractor also had not objected to the extension of the bank guarantees nor raised any claims and therefore, there was no question of making a claim towards additional charges incurred by the Contractor towards extension of the bank guarantees. The issue on liquidated damages was not gone into by the Court since the finding of the arbitral tribunal on the issue of accord and satisfaction and full and final settlement had been upheld.
The Contractor was awarded the work for construction of KLP for IIIrd Infantry Battalion of 60 Infantry Brigade at Delhi Cantonment. The completion of the project was delayed. Thirteen buildings were removed from the scope of the contract with the consent of the Contractor. The disputes between the parties were referred to arbitration.
The arbitral tribunal concluded that the certification of the completion of the project was held up due to the thirteen buildings. Therefore, there was no alternative with Contractor for getting the work completion certificate without signing the said amendment. The amendment to the contract was under coercion. The Employer ought to have descoped these thirteen buildings at the earliest point of time, when the remaining part of the contract stood concluded; but having elected to keep the contract subsisting for 24 months for this purpose, it would have certainly led to the Contractor incurring idling.
The Contractor would not have ordinarily been readily agreeable to descoping. The Court upheld the award of the arbitral tribunal including the finding that the Contractor was entitled to loss of profit from the sale of the scrap of wood and brick recovered from the demolition of the thirteen buildings.
The Court upheld the arbitral award that there was no possibility of the Contractor planning to purchase material before completion of work, which was the basis of freezing indices and that the Whole Sale Price Index (WPI) ought not to be frozen for the extended period. The interpretation of the scope of the tender falls within the arbitral tribunal’s jurisdiction.
RAUTRAY & CO.
Law Firm
Dharmendra Rautray &
Ginny Jetley Rautray
B3/18 Vasant Vihar,
Paschimi Marg,
New Delhi – 110057
Tel: +91.11.46552244 / 46113964
E: mail@rautray.com
Rautray & Co. law firm is a Top Tier ranked firm by Asia Pacific Legal 500 in Dispute Resolution for the years 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.