Construction Arbitration — Issue 90
Modification of liquidated damages
Contract provided for levy of liquidated damages at 2% for a delay of every week subject to a maximum of 20% of the value of the contract - once delay is partly attributable to the Employer, it would not be permissible to apply the clause for liquidated damages without ascertaining the extent of delay attributable to the Employer and modifying compensation accordingly.
No compensation clause
Where the contract provides only for extension of time on the request of the Contractor and delay is solely attributable to the Employer, a defaulting party cannot take advantage of its own wrong - rights available under Sections 55 and 73 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 cannot be waived by the parties - the arbitral tribunal can award damages notwithstanding a contractual provision stipulating extension of time as the remedy.
Employer-attributable delay
Where delay is partly attributable to the Employer, the arbitral tribunal is required to ascertain the extent of delay attributable to the Employer and the compensation must be modified accordingly.
Employer delay and damages
Sections 55 and 73 of the Indian Contract Act are fundamental rights and cannot be waived - damages can be awarded where the Employer's delay prevents completion, notwithstanding a clause providing only for extension of time.
The Employer awarded sub-contract for construction, fabrication and repairs of various kinds of vessels. The contract provided for liquidated damages to be levied at 2% per week of delay up to a maximum of 20% of the contract value. The Employer levied liquidated damages of 20% of the contract value and deducted the same from the bills of the sub-contractor.
The sub-contractor contended that the delay in execution of the works was due to unrealistic work schedules, insufficient work area, not providing crane facility in needed times, delay in supply of consumables and processed elements, delay in clearing inter dependencies, delayed payments for completed works etc. The Employer contended that the delay in completion of the total work resulted in delay in delivery of the vessels due to which the owners of the vessels had levied liquidated damages on the Employer and as such, the Employer is entitled to levy liquidated damages as per the terms of the contract on the Contractor.
Disputes between the parties were referred to arbitration. The arbitral tribunal on the question of the quantum of liquidated damages concluded that neither party were solely responsible for the delays and as such, implementation of the liquidated damages clause cannot be totally waived and a middle ground would have to be arrived at for a fair solution. The arbitral tribunal upheld a part of the liquidated damages amount and directed refund of that part of the liquidated damages which was rejected by the arbitral tribunal.
The Court observed that the owners of the vessels had levied damages against the Employer on account of the delay in the delivery of the vessels. Once the delay is partly attributable to the Employer, it would not be permissible to apply the clause for liquidated damages and it would be the responsibility of the arbitral tribunal to ascertain the extent of delay which is attributable to the Employer and compensation would have to be modified accordingly.
The Employer awarded the contract for new BG Track between Tindivanam and Nagari (via) Walajah Road, proposed construction of Major Bridges, foundations, substructures and superstructures. The scheduled period of contract was for 11 months from the date of issuance letter of award. The contract was delayed for nearly 67 months.
The Contractor’s stand was that there were delays in approving designs and drawings, variations in original work, furnishing centre line and temporary bench mark, clearing hindrances, handing over of work site and entrustment of new work. The Contractor requested the Employer to foreclose the contract owing to indefinite extension of period. The contract was foreclosed. However, no payment was made towards final bill and the monies retained towards Bank Guarantee, security deposit etc. was also not released by the Employer. The Contractor invoked arbitration.
The arbitral tribunal allowed some of the claims of the Contractor but rejected the claim for compensation towards overhead charges during the extended period of contract, escalation cost at the rate of 10% p.a. for the work done beyond the original period, loss of profit and payment of interest. The Contractor contended that the said claims were rejected by the arbitral tribunal solely on the ground that Clause 17A(ii) of the General Conditions of Contract (GCC) provided only for extension of time on the request of the Contractor but no compensation would be payable to the Contractor.
The Court observed that the Employer, Southern Railways, was not able to acquire the land on time and therefore, the entire work could not be completed. Sections 55 and 73 of the Indian Contract Act are heart and soul of the Contract Act and rights available thereunder cannot be waived by the parties. The arbitral tribunal can award damages when there is a delay on the part of the Employer, notwithstanding the clause of the contract stipulating that only extension of time can be given as remedy.
RAUTRAY & CO.
Law Firm
Dharmendra Rautray &
Ginny Jetley Rautray
B3/18 Vasant Vihar,
Paschimi Marg,
New Delhi – 110057
Tel: +91.11.46552244 / 46113964
E: mail@rautray.com
Rautray & Co. law firm is a Top Tier ranked firm by Asia Pacific Legal 500 in Dispute Resolution for the years 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.