Construction Arbitration — Issue 89
Liquidated damages and proof of actual loss
Liquidated damages claim - the expression “whether or not actual damage or loss is proved to have been caused thereby” does not dispense with proof where it is possible to establish actual damage or loss. Where loss is difficult or impossible to quantify, the stipulated amount may be awarded only if it represents a genuine pre-estimate of loss.
Burden of proof for liquidated damages
Proof of damage - the burden lies on the party claiming liquidated damages to demonstrate either the actual loss suffered, or that the stipulated amount was, at the time of contracting, a reasonable and genuine pre-estimate of likely loss based on objective grounds. Foundational pleading and some evidence are required.
Certified IPCs and payment within 60 days
Delay in making payments under Interim Payment Certificates (IPCs) - a running account bill becomes an IPC only if certified - once certified, payment is required within 60 days from the Engineer’s certificate, failing which a fundamental breach may result.
Suspension of work and fundamental breach
Suspension of work - where the Contractor stopped work for 28 days, no stoppage was shown in the current programme and the suspension was not authorised by the Engineer, the suspension constituted a fundamental breach, particularly where it was subsequently abandoned.
The Employer awarded to the Contractor the work for fabrication and supply of aviation refuellers. During execution, several difficulties arose owing to the fact that the chassis models supplied were newly introduced and required extensive modifications to be adapted for refueller application. Additional delays occurred due to the need for first-time importation and installation of certain components in India, redesigning arrangements, and obtaining necessary engineering clearances.
The Employer invoked the liquidated damages clause. The Contractor protested the deductions, contending that the delays were attributable to circumstances beyond its control, particularly the delay in the supply of chassis, technical modifications, and statutory approvals. The Employer contended that time was the essence of the contract and that the deductions represented a genuine pre-estimate of loss occasioned by delay in delivery. The disputes between the parties were referred to arbitration.
The arbitral tribunal rejected the claims of the Contractor. The District Court set aside the arbitral award on the ground that the Employer neither pleaded nor proved actual loss. The Employer claimed operational losses such as impediment to refuelling operations, blockage of funds, and loss of man-hours, which justified the invocation of the clause since the losses could not be precisely quantified.
The High Court observed that where a sum is specified in a contract as liquidated damages payable upon breach, only reasonable compensation can be awarded, and such compensation cannot exceed the amount so stipulated. Furthermore, where it is possible to prove actual damage or loss, such proof cannot be dispensed with. It is only in situations where loss or damage is difficult or impossible to quantify that the liquidated amount specified in the contract, if representing a genuine pre-estimate of probable loss, may be awarded.
It therefore follows that in all cases, whether or not actual loss can be proved, some form of substantiation or evidence is always required from the party claiming such damages. The liquidated damages stipulated in a contract represent merely the upper ceiling of compensation that may be awarded; they do not become automatically payable upon breach.
When it is possible to establish the actual loss, the claimant must adduce cogent evidence demonstrating the extent of the loss suffered as a direct consequence of the breach. However, in cases where it is impracticable or impossible to precisely quantify the loss, the claimant must still establish that the liquidated damages specified in the contract constitute a “genuine pre-estimate of loss” made by the parties at the time of entering into the agreement. This requires showing, with reasonable probability, that the stipulated figure was intended to reflect a fair and bona fide estimate of potential loss, and not imposed as a penalty.
A mere bald or general assertion without any evidentiary foundation cannot satisfy this requirement. Thus, a mere generalized claim that loss might have been incurred due to reasons such as delay or default is insufficient. The burden of proof lies squarely upon the party claiming liquidated damages to demonstrate either the actual loss suffered, or that the stipulated amount was, at the time of contracting, a reasonable and genuine pre-estimate of likely loss based on objective grounds. The Employer neither pleaded nor produced any material to demonstrate its entitlement to damages. A party claiming damages must, at the very least, lay the foundational pleading and provide some evidence to show the occurrence of loss or the basis for claiming compensation. The arbitral tribunal’s award is liable to be set aside.
The Employer awarded a work of construction and maintenance of service ducts on IT Corridor and improvement and maintenance of East Coast Road (ECR) Link Road to the Contractor. The duration of the contract was fixed as 7 months. Due to delay in the completion of works, the first extension was granted for three months. There was a further delay in the completion of works and hence, the second extension of time was granted for two months.
The Contractor took a stand that the Employer did not make any payments for the invoices raised. The Contractor wrote to the Employer stating that they would not be able to continue with the work on account of financial constraints owing to the delay in payment. Only if the pending bills were cleared, the Contractor would be able to resume the work. The Employer informed the Contractor that the contract was terminated since the Contractor suspended the work and committed fundamental breach of the contract.
The arbitral tribunal allowed the counter claim of the Employer towards 20% of the value of the work not executed under the contract. The Court observed that the running account bill submitted by the Contractor becomes an IPC only if the said bill is certified. Once the payment is certified, it has to be paid within a period of 60 days from the date of the Engineer’s certificate, failing which, it will result in the fundamental breach of contract.
Bills were submitted without enclosing the request for inspection (RFI) and the supporting documents. The Contractor did not comply with the contractual requirement. When a contractor stops the work for 28 days, when no stoppage of work was shown in the current programme and when the stoppage has not been authorised by the Engineer, it results in the fundamental breach of the contract on the part of the contractor. Thus, the suspension of work by the Contractor, which was subsequently abandoned, constitutes a fundamental breach of the contract.
RAUTRAY & CO.
Law Firm
Dharmendra Rautray &
Ginny Jetley Rautray
B3/18 Vasant Vihar,
Paschimi Marg,
New Delhi – 110057
Tel: +91.11.46552244 / 46113964
E: mail@rautray.com
Rautray & Co. law firm is a Top Tier ranked firm by Asia Pacific Legal 500 in Dispute Resolution for the years 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.