Rautray Advocates & Solicitors
Issue 88November 2025
C.A.N.

Construction Arbitration

Newsletter
RAUTRAY & CO.
Construction Arbitration Law Firm
www.rautray.com

Construction Arbitration — Issue 88

Claim for escalation during abnormal prolongation

Claim for escalation - abnormal prolongation of contract - contract contained a specific embargo on the payment of price escalation during the contract period and also during the extended period “whatever the reason may be” - no demand for escalation was made by the Contractor prior to the invocation of arbitration - no claim for price escalation was made by the Contractor even during the execution of the contract - requests for extension of time did not contain any notice seeking damages for delayed execution - claim was not supported by any data or calculation - award in favour of Contractor liable to be set aside.

Bharat Heavy Electrical Limited v. M/s Koneru Constructions

No Dues Certificate and economic duress

No Dues Certificate - waiver of all claims - whether submitted due to financial hardship and economic duress - No Dues Certificate issued at the instance of, and as per the format of the Employer - withholding payment of final bill - whether the Contractor has waived its contractual right or is otherwise estopped is a fact for the arbitral tribunal - tribunal should determine whether the No Dues Certificate was given voluntarily or was a product of duress / coercion - award is unreasoned in the absence of such finding.

Bharat Heavy Electrical Limited v. M/s Koneru Constructions

Delay caused by other subcontractors

Delay in completion of the work - work delayed due to other subcontractors - commencement and completion of the Sub-Contractor's scope of work were contingent upon completion of the civil works by the other subcontractor - flooring and cladding activities could not commence until the civil contractor had completed and the work front was made available - arbitral tribunal's finding that termination of the contract was invalid, is correct.

National Building Construction Corporation v. Sharma Enterprises
Bharat Heavy Electrical Limited v. M/s Koneru Constructions
Delhi High Court — Decided on 26.11.2025

The Contractor was awarded the contract for execution of the civil works for a substation at Arasur in Tamil Nadu. The work was completed after a delay of more than 30 months from the scheduled date of completion. Even thereafter, no liquidated damages for delay in completion of the works were imposed by the Employer. The Contractor requested the Employer to make payment for the work done. The Employer asked for submission of a no dues certificate, in full and final settlement of the work order, mentioning the net amount payable. The Contractor submitted a no dues certificate to the Employer and the balance payment was released by the Employer.

The Contractor raised an objection that the no dues certificate submitted by it was not voluntary and was submitted due to financial hardship and economic duress. The disputes between the parties were referred to arbitration. The Contractor raised numerous claims against the Employer. The arbitral tribunal rejected all the claims raised by the Contractor, except the claim relating to loss in escalation of rates due to abnormal prolongation of contract at 10% of the executed value.

The Court observed that the arbitral tribunal should have given a finding on the issue as to whether the ‘No Dues Certificate’ was given voluntarily or whether it was a product of duress / coercion. The award is unreasoned since the arbitral tribunal did not give a finding on the binding effect of the ‘No Dues Certificate’.

Further, the award was unsustainable in granting damages on account of loss suffered due to escalation of rates arising from abnormal prolongation of the contract at 10% of the value of work executed. The contract between the parties contained a specific embargo on the payment of price escalation during the contract period and also during the extended period “whatever the reason may be”. The claim was not predicated on any averment or material as regards (i) the relevant items of which the rates have increased; (ii) the extent to which there was price escalation; and (iii) the impact thereof on the cost of the execution of works. The claim was not supported by any data or calculation. The award of the claim for escalation was liable to be set aside.

National Building Construction Corporation v. Sharma Enterprises
Delhi High Court — Decided on 19.11.2025

The Sub-Contractor was awarded the contract for carrying out flooring and cladding works at the Vashi Railway Station cum commercial complex project in Navi Mumbai. The Principal Contractor was engaged by IRCON / Employer. Disputes between the Sub-Contractor and the Principal Contractor were referred to arbitration.

The arbitral tribunal concluded that the civil contractor had completed only about 7% of the work, making it impossible for the Sub-Contractor to commence flooring and cladding activities as the requisite sites and work fronts were not made available. The Court upheld the arbitral tribunal’s finding that the termination of the contract was invalid.

Further, the Court observed that once it had been held that the delay was not attributable to the Sub-Contractor and that the termination of the contract was not validly effected by the Principal Contractor, the question of withholding the security deposit or insisting upon a completion certificate did not arise.

Authors

RAUTRAY & CO.

Law Firm

Dharmendra Rautray &
Ginny Jetley Rautray

B3/18 Vasant Vihar,
Paschimi Marg,
New Delhi – 110057

Tel: +91.11.46552244 / 46113964
E: mail@rautray.com

Rautray & Co. law firm is a Top Tier ranked firm by Asia Pacific Legal 500 in Dispute Resolution for the years 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.