Construction Arbitration — Issue 87
EPC Contractor’s prolongation costs in a BOT project
EPC Contractor’s prolongation costs in a BOT project - maintainability of claim - whether the Concessionaire could recover EPC Contractor’s prolongation costs from the Employer - EPC Contract not produced in arbitration proceeding - absence of proof EPC Contractor incurred loss - no proof that the Concessionaire indemnified the EPC Contractor - EPC being a back to back agreement duly recognized under the Concession Agreement, any claim of the EPC would, in fact, be a claim of the Concessionaire itself, thereby making it subject of being adjudicated in arbitration proceedings.
Claim on behalf of EPC Contractor for prolongation costs
Claim on behalf of EPC Contractor for prolongation costs - in the absence of the EPC Contract, the mere recommendation of the IE for payment as prolongation costs to the EPC Contractor cannot substitute an actual identified and quantified claim supported by the relevant documentary proof of the existence and details of such a claim.
Recommendation of the Independent Engineer
Recommendation of the Independent Engineer - whether binding on arbitral tribunal - delay in the completion of the project - quantification of the damages or prolongation cost - arbitral tribunal not bound by the law of evidence - arbitral tribunal can rely on IE’s recommendation for the purpose of quantification - on random checks of the original documents and accounts, the IE had certified the claims - an outright rejection of the IE's report merely for lack of perfect accuracy would be unjustified and contrary to the intention underlying the contractual framework.
Employer’s indemnification responsibility
Employer’s indemnification responsibility - contract provided that the Employer would indemnify the Concessionaire against third-party claims for loss, damages, and expenses arising due to any breach by the Employer - back-to-back contractual arrangement between the EPC Contractor and the Concessionaire duly recognized under the contract - need to first make payment to a third party before raising a claim against the indemnifier - Employer denied EPC Contractor’s claim by submitting that the EPC Contractor was not a party to the arbitration agreement and, therefore, its claims could not be adjudicated by the arbitral tribunal - further submitted that there was no document showing any claim being raised by the said EPC Contractor against the Concessionaire - it would be a case where the Concessionaire will agitate the claim of sub-contractor / EPC as being its own claim - in the absence of EPC contract being on record, claim of the Concessionaire, in form of damages or indemnity, could not have been allowed by the arbitral tribunal - indemnity clause cannot get triggered based on an assumption or mere assertion.
Levy of liquidated damages
Levy of liquidated damages - finding on delay in completion of the contract - whether report of the competent authority on delay is final and binding on the parties - no finding was given by the arbitral tribunal as to who was responsible for the delay of 279 days having concluded that 165 days as justifiable delay out of the total extended period of 444 days - arbitral tribunal cannot merely rely on the report of the competent authority and render a finding that such decision taken by the Chief Engineer was final and binding on the parties - arbitral tribunal failed in its duty to give a finding as to who was responsible for the delay.
The Employer awarded the Concessionaire a BOT concession for four-laning NH-2 between Panagarh and Palsit. The completion of construction of the project highway was delayed. The Concessionaire claimed prolongation costs, change-of-law compensation, underpayment for additional works, and interest. The disputes between the parties were referred to arbitration.
The arbitral tribunal rejected the Concessionaire’s claim for EPC Contractor’s prolongation costs on the ground that an indemnity claim requires the existence of a specific third-party claim against the indemnified party and no such claim, nor any evidence of loss suffered by the EPC Contractor, was produced before the arbitral tribunal. The arbitral tribunal observed that EPC Contractor, not being a party to the contract, cannot sustain its claim. There was nothing on record to show that the EPC has incurred any loss and has been indemnified by the Concessionaire.
The Division Bench of the Court concluded EPC being a back-to-back agreement duly recognized under the Concession Agreement, any claim of the EPC would, in fact, be a claim of the Concessionaire itself, thereby making it subject of being adjudicated in arbitration proceedings. It would be a case where the Concessionaire will agitate the claim of sub-contractor / EPC as being its own claim.
However, in the absence of the EPC Contract being on record, the claim of the Concessionaire, in form of damages or indemnity, could not have been allowed by the arbitral tribunal. In the absence of the EPC Contract, the mere recommendation of the IE for payment as prolongation costs to the EPC Contractor cannot substitute an actual identified and quantified claim supported by the relevant documentary proof of the existence and details of such a claim. The production of the EPC Contract could have disclosed whether the EPC Contractor had any contractual entitlement to indemnification.
The Contractor was awarded the work for the construction of an administrative building along with allied development works, including a compound wall, at the Composite Regional Centre in Andhra Pradesh. Disputes arose between the parties during the execution of the work and the settlement of claims. The Contractor raised multiple claims, including claims for release of recovered amounts without levy, escalation, GST reimbursement, overhead charges for the prolonged period, compensation for loss of business, interest, and costs of arbitration.
The Employer contended that the entire delay was attributable to the Contractor and that the claims were unsustainable. The arbitral tribunal allowed some of the claims but rejected the Contractor’s claim for release of the amount levied as liquidated damages by the Employer.
The arbitral tribunal took the view that the recommendations made by the Engineer-in-Charge to the Competent Authority (Chief Engineer) were final and binding on the parties on the issue of delays caused by the Contractor. No finding was given by the arbitral tribunal as to who was responsible for the delay of 279 days, having concluded that 165 days were justifiable delay out of the total extended period of 444 days.
The Court concluded that the arbitral tribunal failed in its duty by not giving a finding as to who was responsible for the delay. The Court accordingly set aside the award on the issue of delay on the part of the Contractor in the completion of the contract.
RAUTRAY & CO.
Law Firm
Dharmendra Rautray &
Ginny Jetley Rautray
B3/18 Vasant Vihar,
Paschimi Marg,
New Delhi – 110057
Tel: +91.11.46552244 / 46113964
E: mail@rautray.com
Rautray & Co. law firm is a Top Tier ranked firm by Asia Pacific Legal 500 in Dispute Resolution for the years 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.